Muskrat Falls presents some significant and massive challenges for Newfoundland and Labrador, ones which almost certainly will require federal government help if the province is to recover from them. First among these is the fact that Hydro-Québec controls the water flows of the Churchill River, via the Churchill Falls reservoir, to the year 2041. Hydro-Québec has been using this practice to great advantage in several ways. It can import power after midnight or at night and conserve water. The water behind the dam at Churchill Falls is enough to supply its generators only about 70% of the time. Thus, by importing US power after midnight at cheap spot rates, it is able to maximize average prices it receives for power. In the day with rush hour in New York, spot rates for power can rise dramatically, and Hydro-Québec can release water into the Churchill Falls generating station. Also, by maximizing power sales at peak summer and winter months, it assures top electricity prices for itself through the peak times.
In the shoulder season when demand is lower, it can cut back electricity production dramatically if needed, so that down the road it can maximize return from the water stored behind the Churchill Falls dams. The power is then sold at the much higher peak prices. The problem for Nalcor’s Muskrat Falls dam, which lies downstream from Churchill Falls, is that the new reservoir has very limited water storage capacity.
Hydro-Québec is going to continue to cut back and vary production from Churchill Falls in its own corporate interests, as it always has done for almost 50 years. Therefore, as Hydro-Québec stores water in the Churchill Falls reservoir, and subsequently cuts production from the Churchill Falls hydro system, this water will be unavailable to the Muskrat Falls system and generating plant. At critical times, Hydro-Québec may only allow enough water downstream so that production from Muskrat Falls will be estimated to be as low as 170 MW or 20% of Muskrat Falls capacity. At 170 MW power, Muskrat Falls produces only 1.5 billion kW. This is barely enough to cover the power the province is obligated to deliver to Nova Scotia’s Emera utility.
And because Muskrat Falls does not have enough water capacity, it can’t arrange long-run power contracts – like the $40 per MW hour contract Hydro-Québec just signed with the state of Massachusetts – due to the fact that Nalcor can’t guarantee the availability of its power, all because it does not control its water supply. Instead, it must try selling spot power at prices likely below $10 per MW hour. Or worse, try and sell it back to Hydro-Québec at whatever that utility wants to pay.
In a sad echo of history, Newfoundland and Labrador has no bargaining position, and is at the mercy of Hydro-Québec’s pricing, just as it was while developing Churchill Falls 40 years ago. Nothing seems to have changed for the province.
Secondly, the initial plan was to have Nalcor’s island-based customers absorb 2 billion kWh themselves, thereby allowing the closure of the thermal based generator at Holyrood and realizing some cost savings. But now, as the price of power doubles to 24 cents per kWh, it is questionable whether Newfoundland and Labrador will ever need the power. This is prohibitive for the residential customer in Newfoundland and Labrador, where half the power is used for heating. Many on the island will turn to wood or otherwise curtail consumption. In the case of the industrial and the commercial customer, the effects will be a massive strain, and energy intensive businesses will struggle to survive. The net effect will be very little increase in demand for power, and the 2 billion kWh destined for Newfoundland and Labrador from Churchill Falls won’t be needed.
Thirdly, in the original plan the 2 billion kWh per year were destined for US customers. However, there is little evidence such customers exist. Not only is there little market for this power but it is unclear that there is even enough transmission grid to carry the power to the customer. Close to 3-4 billion kWh or 50%-80% of Muskrat Falls power could be stranded.
Fourthly, with the uncertainty of having enough water to produce power, the thermal generation station at Holyrood will not be able to close, and that savings of $150 million will not be realized. Holyrood will have to stay open to provide backup power, as the Muskrat Falls transmissions may be unreliable at peak times.
Finally, the annual interest on Muskrat Falls debt is approximately $500 million on the $8 billion of debt guaranteed by the federal government, and the roughly $4 billion that Newfoundland and Labrador borrowed to increase its equity investment in Muskrat Falls. This principal, plus the interest, ultimately must be repaid by the province. This is impossible without federal help. Newfoundland and Labrador was in trouble even before Muskrat Falls, but this development has created an impossible predicament.